BCBA® task H.4 · Area H
H.4 Anticipating unwanted effects of reinforcement, extinction and punishment
3 min read · BCBA® Test Content Outline, 6th edition
What it means
When reinforcement for a behavior is withheld, responding may briefly rise, vary or intensify, and emotional behavior or aggression can appear. Punishment can be accompanied by escape or avoidance of associated people or places, emotional responding, aggression, or suppression restricted to conditions in which the punishing stimulus or event is expected. Reinforcement has its own risks: satiation, dependence on a single contrived reward, or more of a behavior than anyone wanted. A sound plan names these effects in advance and says what to do about them: prepare the people carrying it out, define a consistent response and a safety plan, reinforce an alternative behavior, and measure more than the target so that collateral effects show up in the data.
Everyday example
A school stops letting a student leave class when he rips his worksheets. The plan warns staff that ripping may increase for a few days, gives them a short script and a safety procedure, teaches the student to hand over a break card, and adds two extra counts: leaving the room without permission and reports of outbursts at home, in case the problem shifts somewhere else.
Common confusion
An early increase during extinction is not, by itself, proof that the plan failed; it was foreseeable, and the plan should say how it will be judged. It is not something to shrug off either: if it involves harm, the safety plan applies. Tracking only the target behavior can hide side effects. And a reduction procedure used on its own, with no reinforcement for an alternative, leaves the person without a better way to get what they need.
Key points
- Extinction can produce a temporary increase (extinction burst), emotional behavior or aggression; the plan warns implementers, sets a consistent response and a safety plan, and reinforces an alternative.
- Punishment can produce escape and avoidance, emotional responding, aggression and suppression limited to the punisher or setting; it is paired with reinforcement for an alternative and monitored.
- Reinforcement procedures also carry risks, such as satiation, dependence on one contrived reinforcer and excessive or unwanted responding, which the plan anticipates.
- Mitigation includes measuring behaviors beyond the target and responding to collateral effects as soon as the data show them.
Examples from practice
Example 1
Before parents stop answering their son's attention-maintained shouting, the analyst tells them it may increase briefly, writes a short script with them, and plans attention for quiet play.
Example 2
For a strong adolescent with a history of hitting when demands continued, staff learn a safety procedure and he is taught a break request before escape extinction begins.
Non-example
A coach starts having a swimmer finish every drill despite her complaints, without telling the assistant coaches. When the complaints get louder, an assistant lets her skip the drill.
Check yourself
One question from the course lesson on this task. Choose an answer to see why it is right or wrong.
On the first two days of extinction for a child's attention-maintained whining, whining lasts longer than in baseline. No one is at risk, and the parents are following the plan and want to continue. What is the best interpretation?
-
Not quite. Two days of increase during extinction is not proof of failure; it was a foreseeable effect that the plan said how to judge.
-
Not quite. Adding punishment brings its own side effects and is not needed to get through a foreseeable increase.
-
Correct. The increase fits a possible extinction burst; with no risk and parents who agree, the team keeps the plan and watches the data.
-
Not quite. Attention at the peak reinforces more intense whining, the very outcome the plan is meant to avoid.
Show the answer and the explanations
Answer: C. An early increase was foreseeable; keep monitoring
- a. Two days of increase during extinction is not proof of failure; it was a foreseeable effect that the plan said how to judge.
- b. Adding punishment brings its own side effects and is not needed to get through a foreseeable increase.
- c. Correct. The increase fits a possible extinction burst; with no risk and parents who agree, the team keeps the plan and watches the data.
- d. Attention at the peak reinforces more intense whining, the very outcome the plan is meant to avoid.
The full lesson is in the course
The course lesson on this task goes further, with more sections, more examples and more practice questions, and keeps a record of what you have mastered.
Try a sample free, without an account
Key terms
Each term opens its definition in the ABA glossary.
All tasks in area H All 104 tasks ABA glossary: every term in one page
Independent study resource. INTERLAZA is not affiliated with or endorsed by the BACB. The explanations and examples are original, are not official exam content and do not reproduce any exam item.