BCBA® task G.18 · Area G
G.18 Emotional and elicited side effects
3 min read · BCBA® Test Content Outline, 6th edition
What it means
Reduction procedures can have effects beyond the target behavior. During extinction, the behavior may briefly increase, become more varied or intense, come with emotional responding or aggression, and return briefly after a break; none of these is certain. Punishment and other aversive procedures can elicit emotional reactions and aggression and can lead the person to escape or avoid the people and places involved, which may come to function as conditioned aversive stimuli. Behavioral contrast can occur when changing the reinforcement arrangement in one component is accompanied by an opposite change in responding in another component whose reinforcement arrangement remains unchanged; behavior worsening elsewhere should be assessed before being labeled contrast. Good plans anticipate all of this.
Everyday example
At a day program, staff stop giving snacks when a man cries for them and start reinforcing his requests instead. For two days the crying gets louder, and once he pushes a chair. Staff had warned his family, had a safety plan ready and kept reinforcing requests; by the second week the crying is rare.
Common confusion
A burst during extinction does not mean the procedure has failed, and a brief return after a break is consistent with spontaneous recovery rather than proof of failure. Aggression appearing during extinction may be elicited, belong to the same operant response class, or have other controlling variables; its timing alone does not establish its function, so assess it and apply the safety plan. Behavior in other settings is worth watching too.
Key points
- Extinction can produce a temporary increase in the behavior (extinction burst), emotional responding and aggression, and later spontaneous recovery.
- Punishment and other aversive procedures can elicit emotional reactions and aggression, and can evoke escape and avoidance of the people and settings involved.
- People and settings paired with aversive procedures or heavy demands can become conditioned aversive stimuli; reducing behavior in one setting can increase it in another setting whose contingencies did not change (behavioral contrast).
- Plans anticipate these effects: inform caregivers, prepare safety measures, combine reduction procedures with reinforcement and track collateral behavior.
Examples from practice
Example 1
A retired man's repeated phone calls to his son, maintained by long chats, go unanswered except at the agreed evening time. For three days the calls double, then they decline.
Example 2
A child's whining for the tablet had stopped under extinction. After a week at her grandparents' house, she whines a few times on the first day back, then stops while the tablet is still withheld.
Non-example
A boy's yelling keeps rising because his aide still answers it about half the time. Reinforcement has not been discontinued, so this is not an extinction burst.
Check yourself
One question from the course lesson on this task. Choose an answer to see why it is right or wrong.
A woman's attention-maintained interruptions at a day program are placed on extinction. On the second day they are louder and more frequent than in any baseline session. Staff ask whether to stop. What is the best response?
-
Not quite. An early increase is consistent with an extinction burst, which does not by itself mean failure.
-
Not quite. A louder version appearing as reinforcement stops does not establish a new function; that would need assessment.
-
Correct. Review safety and implementation and keep reinforcing alternatives; the pattern fits a burst.
-
Not quite. Attention after the loudest episodes would reinforce the intensified responding.
Show the answer and the explanations
Answer: C. Check safety and integrity; an early rise can be a burst
- a. An early increase is consistent with an extinction burst, which does not by itself mean failure.
- b. A louder version appearing as reinforcement stops does not establish a new function; that would need assessment.
- c. Correct. Review safety and implementation and keep reinforcing alternatives; the pattern fits a burst.
- d. Attention after the loudest episodes would reinforce the intensified responding.
The full lesson is in the course
The course lesson on this task goes further, with more sections, more examples and more practice questions, and keeps a record of what you have mastered.
Try a sample free, without an account
Key terms
Each term opens its definition in the ABA glossary.
All tasks in area G All 104 tasks ABA glossary: every term in one page
Independent study resource. INTERLAZA is not affiliated with or endorsed by the BACB. The explanations and examples are original, are not official exam content and do not reproduce any exam item.