BCBA® task F.5 · Area F
F.5 Descriptive and indirect assessment
3 min read · BCBA® Test Content Outline, 6th edition
What it means
Indirect assessment gathers information from people who know the person, through interviews, rating scales and questionnaires; it is fast but only as accurate as the informant. Descriptive assessment means watching the behavior where it happens and recording what comes before and after it, without changing anything: narrative ABC notes, structured ABC checklists or a scatterplot. A scatterplot shows when behavior clusters across the day, which tells you when to look; it does not tell you why. Both kinds of data show what goes together, which is useful for forming a hypothesis but not for proving one.
Everyday example
Over two weeks of structured ABC recording, nearly every outburst in a preschool class is followed by a staff member kneeling to talk with the child. That makes attention a strong guess. But staff also kneel to talk with that child often when there has been no outburst, so the pattern alone cannot show that attention maintains the behavior.
Common confusion
Do not mix up the two names: indirect means someone reports, descriptive means someone observes directly. Neither manipulates anything, so neither is a functional analysis. A consequence that often follows a behavior may follow it just as often when the behavior does not occur, which is why comparing those two probabilities helps.
Key points
- Descriptive assessment is direct observation of behavior and surrounding events in natural conditions, without manipulating variables (narrative ABC, structured ABC, scatterplot).
- A scatterplot shows when behavior tends to occur across time periods; it points to times worth examining, not to a function.
- Descriptive data show correlations, not causes; comparing how often an event follows behavior with how often it occurs otherwise helps form hypotheses to test.
- Indirect assessment (interviews, rating scales, questionnaires) relies on informant report; it is quick but depends on the informant's accuracy.
- A useful descriptive assessment needs an operational definition, trained observers and observations scheduled when and where the behavior is likely.
Examples from practice
Example 1
A residential counselor completes a 20-item questionnaire about the situations in which a resident throws objects. This is indirect assessment: it rests on the counselor's recollection.
Example 2
During normal shifts at a supported-employment site, a job coach notes each time a worker leaves his station and what happened just before and after. This is descriptive assessment.
Non-example
In an intake interview, a grandmother describes in great detail what happens before and after her grandson spits. The detail is rich, but it is still a report from memory, so it is indirect assessment, not descriptive.
Check yourself
One question from the course lesson on this task. Choose an answer to see why it is right or wrong.
For five days, a school counselor sits in the cafeteria at lunch and writes down what happens just before and after each time a student grabs food from peers. Nothing about lunch is changed. Which kind of assessment is this?
-
Not quite. Who observes does not decide the type. The counselor watches and records events directly, which makes it descriptive.
-
Correct. Direct observation in natural conditions, with nothing manipulated, is descriptive assessment.
-
Not quite. A functional analysis arranges and changes conditions. Here lunch runs as usual, so nothing is tested experimentally.
-
Not quite. Notes taken while watching are a direct record. Indirect assessment relies on recollection through interviews or rating scales.
Show the answer and the explanations
Answer: B. Descriptive, since events are recorded as they occur
- a. Who observes does not decide the type. The counselor watches and records events directly, which makes it descriptive.
- b. Correct. Direct observation in natural conditions, with nothing manipulated, is descriptive assessment.
- c. A functional analysis arranges and changes conditions. Here lunch runs as usual, so nothing is tested experimentally.
- d. Notes taken while watching are a direct record. Indirect assessment relies on recollection through interviews or rating scales.
The full lesson is in the course
The course lesson on this task goes further, with more sections, more examples and more practice questions, and keeps a record of what you have mastered.
Try a sample free, without an account
Key terms
Each term opens its definition in the ABA glossary.
All tasks in area F All 104 tasks ABA glossary: every term in one page
Independent study resource. INTERLAZA is not affiliated with or endorsed by the BACB. The explanations and examples are original, are not official exam content and do not reproduce any exam item.