BCBA® task D.8 · Area D

D.8 Comparative, component and parametric analyses

2 min read · BCBA® Test Content Outline, 6th edition

What it means

These analyses refine a treatment instead of only asking whether it works. A comparative analysis sets two or more different interventions against each other to see which is more effective or efficient. A component analysis takes a treatment package apart, removing elements from the full package or adding them one at a time, to learn which parts are necessary or sufficient. A parametric analysis keeps a single independent variable and compares different values of it: its amount, intensity, duration or how often it is delivered.

Everyday example

A feeding program combines praise, a sip of a favorite drink after each bite and a picture chart of the plate. Running it with and without the chart is a component analysis. One sip per bite against one sip per three bites is parametric. The whole program against an entirely different video-modeling procedure is comparative.

Common confusion

Component means parts of one package; comparative means different treatments; parametric means different values of one variable. A functional analysis asks which environmental contingencies influence the target behavior; comparative, component and parametric analyses describe what is compared or varied, so these labels can also describe comparisons made within a functional analysis.

Key points

  • A comparative analysis tests two or more different interventions against each other to find which is more effective or efficient.
  • A component analysis separates the parts of a treatment package, by removing or adding them, to find which are necessary or sufficient.
  • A parametric analysis compares different values of one independent variable, such as amount, intensity, frequency or duration.
  • These analyses are chosen to make treatments more efficient: dropping unnecessary components, choosing the better procedure or finding an effective level.

Examples from practice

Example 1

A school compares a written checklist with a peer-buddy system for getting a student to the bus on time, alternating the two across days.

Example 2

A clinic compares text reminders with phone calls for helping families arrive on time, switching the method each week.

Non-example

Comparing 10-minute and 20-minute sessions of the same tutoring program changes only the amount of one variable; that is parametric, not comparative.

Check yourself

One question from the course lesson on this task. Choose an answer to see why it is right or wrong.

A team compares picture prompts and video prompts for teaching an adult two equally difficult cooking tasks, one task per method. The picture task is mastered in 5 sessions, the video task in 9. Which conclusion fits?

Show the answer and the explanations

Answer: B. The picture task needed fewer sessions here

  • a. This pair of tasks does not establish an advantage for every new task.
  • b. Correct. The data show sessions to mastery for these two tasks, and the conclusion stays within that.
  • c. Session length and total time were not reported, so fewer sessions do not establish less teaching time.

The full lesson is in the course

The course lesson on this task goes further, with more sections, more examples and more practice questions, and keeps a record of what you have mastered.

Open the lesson Practice this task

Try a sample free, without an account

Key terms

Each term opens its definition in the ABA glossary.

All tasks in area D All 104 tasks ABA glossary: every term in one page

Independent study resource. INTERLAZA is not affiliated with or endorsed by the BACB. The explanations and examples are original, are not official exam content and do not reproduce any exam item.