BCBA® task D.2 · Area D

D.2 Internal and external validity

3 min read · BCBA® Test Content Outline, 6th edition

What it means

Internal validity asks one question of a particular study: can the change in the dependent variable be credited to the independent variable, rather than to something else happening at the same time? It grows with experimental control, which in single-case work comes from repeating the effect inside the design. External validity asks whether the relation holds beyond the study, with other people, settings, behaviors, times or versions of the procedure; behavior analysts call this generality. Single-case research builds it through replication: direct replication repeats the procedure as it was, systematic replication deliberately varies some feature of it.

Everyday example

A token system cuts call-outs for one third-grader, and the effect disappears and returns each time the tokens are removed and restored: strong internal validity. Whether it will work for her classmates, in music class or with another teacher is a separate question, answered only by trying it there: external validity.

Common confusion

The two are judged separately. A study can show tight control with one person and still say little about anyone else, and a large sample does not by itself make a result trustworthy or general. Social validity is a third, different question: whether the goals, procedures and results matter to and are accepted by the people involved. Interobserver agreement is a fourth: how much the measurement itself can be trusted.

Key points

  • Internal validity is the degree to which a change in the dependent variable can be attributed to the independent variable rather than to uncontrolled factors.
  • External validity is the degree to which a functional relation holds for other participants, settings, behaviors, times or versions of the procedure (generality).
  • In single-case research, generality is built through direct and systematic replication rather than through large samples.
  • Internal validity, external validity, social validity and measurement reliability answer different questions and are judged separately.

Examples from practice

Example 1

Unsafe lifts by a warehouse worker drop each of the three times a coaching procedure is introduced and climb each time it is paused: strong internal validity.

Example 2

A girl's reading practice increases the week a reward chart starts, which is also the week her grandmother moves in to help with homework: internal validity is weakened.

Non-example

A study with 200 participants is not internally valid for that reason alone. If a holiday break coincided with the treatment, the rival explanation is still there.

Check yourself

One question from the course lesson on this task. Choose an answer to see why it is right or wrong.

A clinic starts a feeding procedure for a toddler the same week her daycare changes its lunch menu. Bites accepted increase. What does the menu change most weaken?

Show the answer and the explanations

Answer: C. Whether the increase came from the procedure

  • a. Applying to other toddlers is external validity. The menu change raises a different problem in this study.
  • b. Parent acceptability concerns social validity. The stem does not assess it; the menu change most directly weakens attribution of the increase to the procedure.
  • c. Correct. The new menu arrived with the procedure, so either could explain the increase. That weakens internal validity.
  • d. Observer agreement concerns the reliability of the measure. A menu change does not alter how bites are recorded.

The full lesson is in the course

The course lesson on this task goes further, with more sections, more examples and more practice questions, and keeps a record of what you have mastered.

Open the lesson Practice this task

Try a sample free, without an account

Key terms

Each term opens its definition in the ABA glossary.

All tasks in area D All 104 tasks ABA glossary: every term in one page

Independent study resource. INTERLAZA is not affiliated with or endorsed by the BACB. The explanations and examples are original, are not official exam content and do not reproduce any exam item.