BCBA® task C.2 · Area C
C.2 Direct, indirect and permanent-product measures
3 min read · BCBA® Test Content Outline, 6th edition
What it means
Direct measurement scores the target behavior itself through observation, either live or from a recording. The observer can be a behavior analyst, a teacher, a parent or the person themselves; the source of the record, rather than the observer’s job title or the time of scoring, distinguishes direct observation from a recalled account. Indirect measurement records something other than the behavior itself and infers the behavior from it, most often accounts given after the fact: interviews, rating scales and checklists filled in from memory. Because they depend on recall and judgment, they help with planning but are weaker evidence of how much behavior occurred. Permanent-product measurement counts the lasting effects a behavior leaves in the environment, such as solved problems on a page or assembled kits, after the behavior is over. It is sound when every occurrence leaves the same product, the product cannot appear some other way, and it can be traced to the person whose behavior is being measured.
Everyday example
A store wants to count kits assembled by an employee. Tallying each completed kit while observing her work is direct measurement. Asking the manager on Friday how many she assembled is indirect. Counting her uniquely labeled completed kits at closing is permanent-product measurement, provided each completed kit leaves one retained product, no one else produces a product with her label, and none are removed or counted twice.
Common confusion
A data sheet, log or tally is where a direct observation is written down; it is not a permanent product of the behavior. And permanent-product data are not indirect just because nobody watched: they count real results of the behavior, not somebody’s memory of it.
Key points
- Direct measurement records the target behavior itself, live or from a recording; what makes it direct is what is measured, not whether the observer is a behavior analyst, a caregiver or other staff.
- Indirect measurement records something other than the behavior itself and infers the behavior from it, usually reports made after the fact, such as interviews, rating scales and checklists completed from memory, so it rests on someone's recollection.
- Permanent-product measurement counts lasting effects attributable to the target behavior and person, with other sources excluded. Inferring response count requires a known response–product relation; measuring products such as new injuries need not establish the number or duration of responses.
- A form, log or tally that records behavior is a data sheet, not a permanent product of the behavior; choosing among the three kinds of measure weighs convenience against how much inference the data require.
Examples from practice
Example 1
A shop assistant clicks a counter each time she greets a customer during her shift. She is measuring her own behavior directly.
Example 2
A grandfather fills in a weekly form rating how often his grandson had trouble settling at night: never, sometimes or often. That is indirect.
Non-example
A parent who marks each sibling fight on a chart the moment it happens is not giving an indirect report, even though she is not a trained observer.
Check yourself
One question from the course lesson on this task. Choose an answer to see why it is right or wrong.
A football coach watches each practice and marks every dropped pass on a clipboard as it happens. The behavior analyst who consults for the team reads the clipboard weekly. How are these data classified?
-
Not quite. Who reads the data later does not matter; the coach recorded each instance as it happened.
-
Correct. Recording each instance as it occurs is direct measurement, whoever the observer is.
-
Not quite. Training affects data quality, not the type of measure. The record was made in the moment.
Show the answer and the explanations
Answer: B. Direct, since each drop is marked when it occurs
- a. Who reads the data later does not matter; the coach recorded each instance as it happened.
- b. Correct. Recording each instance as it occurs is direct measurement, whoever the observer is.
- c. Training affects data quality, not the type of measure. The record was made in the moment.
The full lesson is in the course
The course lesson on this task goes further, with more sections, more examples and more practice questions, and keeps a record of what you have mastered.
Try a sample free, without an account
Key terms
Each term opens its definition in the ABA glossary.
All tasks in area C All 104 tasks ABA glossary: every term in one page
Independent study resource. INTERLAZA is not affiliated with or endorsed by the BACB. The explanations and examples are original, are not official exam content and do not reproduce any exam item.