BCBA® task B.19 · Area B
B.19 Verbal operants
3 min read · BCBA® Test Content Outline, 6th edition
What it means
Classify verbal operants by their controlling variables and reinforcement history, rather than by the word alone. A mand is controlled by an MO and a history of obtaining a characteristic consequence. A tact is controlled by nonverbal stimulation and typically a history of generalized conditioned reinforcement. An echoic involves a vocal verbal stimulus and vocal responding with point-to-point correspondence and formal similarity. An intraverbal is controlled by verbal stimulation without point-to-point correspondence. Textual behavior reads written verbal stimuli aloud; taking dictation, called transcription here, writes what is heard. Both have point-to-point correspondence without formal similarity. These nonmand operants are typically established through generalized conditioned reinforcement; every occurrence need not receive praise. An autoclitic depends on other verbal behavior of the speaker and changes its effect on a listener. Fetching an object when asked illustrates nonverbal listener responding.
Everyday example
The word "water" can be five operants. Thirsty, you say "water" and get a glass: mand. You see a puddle and say "water": tact. You repeat "water" after hearing it: echoic. "What do fish swim in?" "Water": intraverbal. You read WATER aloud from a label: textual.
Common confusion
Mand and tact are told apart by their controlling variables, not by the word: a motivating operation and a specific reinforcer point to a mand; a nonverbal stimulus and generalized reinforcement point to a tact. Fetching an item when asked illustrates nonverbal listener responding. An instruction can also evoke speaker behavior, such as an echoic response to “Say water.”
Key points
- Each verbal operant is defined by its controlling antecedent and consequence, not by the words said.
- A mand involves an MO and reinforcement characteristic of that mand. A tact involves nonverbal stimulation. Echoic responding has point-to-point correspondence and formal similarity with a vocal verbal model; intraverbal responding lacks point-to-point correspondence. Nonmand verbal operants are typically established through generalized conditioned reinforcement.
- Reading aloud and taking dictation are codic relations: point-to-point correspondence without formal similarity. Echoic responding, verbal sign imitation and copying written text are duplic relations: point-to-point correspondence with formal similarity. Here, transcription refers specifically to taking dictation.
- An autoclitic is verbal behavior that depends on the speaker's own verbal behavior and modifies its effect on the listener.
- Listener responding includes nonverbal responses to verbal stimuli, such as selecting an item or following an instruction. Listeners can also mediate a speaker's reinforcement; this role does not mean that every listener response is a speaker verbal operant or that a listener cannot also emit speaker behavior.
Examples from practice
Example 1
Mand: a commuter whose phone is at 2% asks a stranger, "Charger?" and stops asking once he is handed one.
Example 2
Tact: on a walk, a woman points and says "heron!" Her friend says "Oh, nice!" and they keep walking; she does not try to get the heron.
Non-example
A man sees an uncaptioned photograph of a pizza, says “pizza,” and receives acknowledgment. No spoken or written model is present, and no MO or history of obtaining pizza through that response is specified. Naming food alone does not establish a mand; the stated control supports a tact.
Check yourself
One question from the course lesson on this task. Choose an answer to see why it is right or wrong.
Looking out of the office window, Dina says "snow!" Her coworker replies, "Wow, look at that," and Dina returns to her work without asking for anything. Dina's response is best classified as:
-
Not quite. An echoic repeats a vocal model. There was no model to repeat.
-
Correct. A nonverbal stimulus (the snow) controls the response, and social acknowledgment follows.
-
Not quite. There is no sign of an MO or a specific consequence she is trying to obtain.
-
Not quite. An intraverbal is controlled by a verbal stimulus. Nobody said anything before "snow."
Show the answer and the explanations
Answer: B. A tact
- a. An echoic repeats a vocal model. There was no model to repeat.
- b. Correct. A nonverbal stimulus (the snow) controls the response, and social acknowledgment follows.
- c. There is no sign of an MO or a specific consequence she is trying to obtain.
- d. An intraverbal is controlled by a verbal stimulus. Nobody said anything before "snow."
The full lesson is in the course
The course lesson on this task goes further, with more sections, more examples and more practice questions, and keeps a record of what you have mastered.
Try a sample free, without an account
Key terms
Each term opens its definition in the ABA glossary.
All tasks in area B All 104 tasks ABA glossary: every term in one page
Independent study resource. INTERLAZA is not affiliated with or endorsed by the BACB. The explanations and examples are original, are not official exam content and do not reproduce any exam item.